OLS1: Linearity of the Regression Model. Linear Regression with One Regressor Outline •1. For example, you might be interested in estimating how workers’ wages (W) depends on the job experience (X), age (A) and education level (E) of the worker. %PDF-1.5 In the primary source, we directly collect data from the source (Original) for example by getting some survey form filled and in the secondary data we use existing data repositories and sources such as newspapers etc for doing the regression analysis. Three variables have a negative relationship with the dependent variable ‘y’ and other variables have a positive relationship. This value is not unusual enough to reject the null hypothesis and model is significant. %���� 9��xm�~��1F��vI���B��1vZ��{��������s�p��#��uH
Ս�CE ��T�y�dJ1. Technically, linear regression estimates how much Y changes when X changes one unit. But, clearly here it seems to be a useless exercise to build this model. For the sake of simplicity, Let’s take an example and build a regression model to understand the whole process using following data and eight variables (represented as X1,x2 ...Xn in the regression model) . logit, ologit) often have the same general format and many of the same options. No matter, what the outcome of the regression is following three steps are followed for doing regression analysis. 5) Model Significance: The values of the p-test are small and closer to zero (<0.5) From this it can be inferred that there is greater evidence that there is little significant difference in the population and the sample. ���fm���v�vFp\���u�sD%�ќr�V�����?�m=Kc�4E�i��c@'�#R����4�3�$�N�o3!㬭��+�Ui�n�m��d��2/s��E)!�h4�X".A��!B�S�j��M��U,"qE#�E$�w ��%��)r0)�qs���&���Y]d�v}�f��v݆!�H�Wp�bb�V$ɰ$�K��h�ZYF>,�o+pn��R`��]��5/�D���,�9��u�_�Ϧ��:Y�s�tf��r[���3��+�g)���Sg��{����@����]m}����y��:}�T�ևٜ@$��������ٔ�k��!+��zʍ�t���#e.�@D*ǐ�i�b�v�A��ʵ.u�o�q��� %2�^��#������ �����ݑ�ރ�;')SH��R�C��ݗ|�T�qB���JNci_�� TL_�ˀ�î�T�U�v� �̒xP�ۧ���,Uq�U7mQ��L�|�Z���K��)�ȯ�ػJ�6$�d���)���~�BRL�W���%����P�@��h0�_A�N��T*�/�X6)-A �f}7))E� >ih�( ���S��h0����R��.|�ԂI6��8(l
�l�� = All these properties of data impact the outcome of the process of regression. >> Linear Regression is the family of algorithms employed in supervised machine learning tasks (to lear n more about supervised learning, you can read my former article here).Knowing that supervised ML tasks are normally divided into classification and regression, we can collocate Linear Regression algorithms in the latter category. But the value of R square (Zero) gives us a different interpretation. But is it Good or Bad contribution to GDP Once you are able to organize the waste, then making it more is not that annoying, but if the waste is spread around you, then trouble is in front, and you think a hundred times before adding it further. Actually waste is development, but, it appears that development is the process of converting natural resources into waste. The conditions of the light are also shown. endobj The purpose of this mixture is to act as a wall plaster, not necessarily as mortar mixture. date,time edt, temp c, spcond (ms/cm), ph,do (mg/l), do (%),turbidity (fnu),chlorophyll (rfu),phycocyanin (rfu), sysbattery, 5/11/2018,13:15:00,19.47,0.74,7.23,7.73,84.29,1.88,2.35,0.72,13.4, 5/11/2018,13:30:00,19.37,0.74,7.23,7.72,84.01,1.72,2.24,0.67,14.01, 5/11/2018,13:45:00,19.58,0.74,7.26,7.87,85.97,1.74,2.02,0.7,13.91, 5/11/2018,14:00:00,19.4,0.74,7.23,7.67,83.56,1.94,2.18,0.69,13.53, 5/11/2018,14:15:00,19.36,0.74,7.23,7.71,83.94,1.79,2.56,0.74,13.93, 5/11/2018,14:30:00,19.96,0.74,7.29,8.11,89.29,1.89,2.26,0.64,14.01, 5/11/2018,14:45:00,20.19,0.74,7.32,8.22,90.97,1.77,2.25,0.67,13.53, 5/11/2018,15:00:00,20.31,0.74,7.33,8.29,91.93,1.7,2.02,0.7,13.92, 5/11/2018,15:15:00,20.44,0.74,7.34,8.33,92.62,1.67,2.26,0.69,13.95, 5/11/2018,15:30:00,20.48,0.74,7.36,8.43,93.77,1.77,2.21,0.65,13.54, 5/11/2018,15:45:00,20.52,0.74,7.35,8.41,93.59,1.68,2.33,0.69,13.83, 5/11/2018,16:00:00,20.31,0.74,7.33,8.32,92.25,1.7,2.56,0.75,13.84, 5/11/2018,16:15:00,20.27,0.74,7.31,8.33,92.3,1.79,2.55,0.72,13.95, 5/11/2018,16:30:00,20.51,0.74,7.38,8.51,94.75,1.8,2.57,0.74,13.76, 5/11/2018,16:45:00,20.23,0.74,7.33,8.34,92.29,1.86,2.3,0.73,13.84, 5/11/2018,17:00:00,20.44,0.74,7.35,8.45,93.98,1.81,2.61,0.75,13.81, 5/11/2018,17:15:00,20.46,0.74,7.35,8.44,93.91,1.82,2.67,0.78,13.83, 5/11/2018,17:30:00,20.23,0.74,7.31,8.28,91.67,1.87,2.76,0.76,13.4, 5/11/2018,17:45:00,20.18,0.74,7.3,8.28,91.61,1.96,2.84,0.74,13.65, 5/11/2018,18:00:00,20.27,0.74,7.31,8.33,92.25,1.83,2.6,0.75,13.51, 5/11/2018,18:15:00,20.25,0.74,7.31,8.22,91.04,1.81,2.67,0.7,13.27, 5/11/2018,18:30:00,20.22,0.74,7.3,8.24,91.24,1.88,2.5,0.7,13.34, 5/11/2018,18:45:00,20.23,0.74,7.32,8.35,92.41,1.85,3.36,0.7,13.1, 5/11/2018,19:00:00,20.09,0.74,7.29,8.19,90.43,1.91,2.44,0.7,12.99, 5/11/2018,19:15:00,19.99,0.74,7.27,8.09,89.16,1.78,2.98,0.72,12.92, 5/11/2018,19:30:00,20,0.74,7.27,8.11,89.43,1.82,2.86,0.79,12.87, 5/11/2018,19:45:00,19.98,0.74,7.26,8.07,88.84,1.86,2.69,0.75,12.83, 5/11/2018,20:00:00,19.9,0.74,7.26,8.03,88.37,1.88,2.43,0.71,12.83, 5/11/2018,20:15:00,19.84,0.74,7.26,8.07,88.71,1.78,2.77,0.73,12.9, 5/11/2018,20:30:00,19.75,0.74,7.25,8,87.69,1.86,2.57,0.67,12.8, 5/11/2018,20:45:00,19.7,0.74,7.23,7.87,86.2,1.73,2.51,0.77,12.79, 5/11/2018,21:00:00,19.63,0.74,7.21,7.8,85.35,1.84,2.48,0.69,12.78, 5/11/2018,21:15:00,19.6,0.74,7.21,7.8,85.26,1.83,2.63,0.71,12.87, 5/11/2018,21:30:00,19.58,0.74,7.21,7.74,84.61,1.73,2.75,0.68,12.89, 5/11/2018,21:45:00,19.54,0.74,7.2,7.67,83.79,1.75,2.61,0.71,12.77. xtset country year If real cleanliness is required then the production of waste will have to be reduced, the consumption will have to be reduced, the rest is eye-wash. Stata: Visualizing Regression Models Using coefplot Partiallybased on Ben Jann’s June 2014 presentation at the 12thGerman Stata Users Group meeting in Hamburg, Germany: “A new command for plotting regression coefficients and other estimates” The purpose of this exercise what not to build or find a good fitting model but to learn about the statistical metrics involved in the Regression Analysis. I got introduced to product “ Vedic Plaster ” some two years ago when I saw it’s the application at Bhopal, Sehatvan. OLS in stata • To run a simple OLS regression, type: –reg dependent_var independent_variables, options –The options may include: •robust : it is recommended to use robust option as it may handle the issue of the heterogeneity of unknown form. << Showing that, this model cannot be improved further. Vedic Plaster Office What is Vedic Plaster? No interpretation as regards to standard deviation of data can be made from it. The focus of this course is on application and interpretation of regression. This book is composed of four chapters covering a variety of topics about using Stata for regression. The estimate may be stable or numerically highly sensitive in nature. OLS diagnostic statistics are introduced including Ramsey's RESET test, multicollinearity tests, heteroskedasticity tests, and residual diagnostic plots. That had positive and negatively correlated variables and hard to fit data values. Before applying panel data regression, the first step is to disregard the effects of space and time and perform pooled regression instead. The least squares assumptions •5. The location of the wall(s ) and the source of water can be observed from the diagram and you can correlate with walls at your home. The nature of the variables and the hypothesized relationship between the variables affect which choice of regression is to be used. In this model the Cond no values is low . There are eight variables (X1,x2,x3 ...X8 ) independent variables and y is the dependent variables. This is because a raised bed would store more volume of soil and will have a better mico-ecosystem as compared to the ecosystem of plastic containers. Hence, to map the relationships between the variables the regression methods chance to using linear or non-linear methods. Interpreting regression models • Often regression results are presented in a table format, which makes it hard for interpreting effects of interactions, of categorical variables or effects in a non-linear models. is greater than 0, which means the model is significant. Another way to run the linear regression in Stata is to type the command in the command window. I recently also made a trip to his Dr Shiv Dharshan Malik’s place Rohtak . Total Number of Observations used for building this model are 9000. in this experiment, are equal to 0. When running a regression we are making two assumptions, 1) there is a linear relationship between two variables (i.e. OLS estimation, the properties and asymptotics of OLS estimators are based on four main assumptions. There are primarily two ways by which we can obtain data for regression: Primary source and Secondary source. Interpretation of STATA Output for Dummy Variable Regression The value of α1 is 0.6007225, which implies that on an average male earns a minimum hourly wage (with no experience and education) in logarithmic terms equal to 0.6007225. Can Vedic plaster be used for Bathroom floor and wall? In that paper, it'd discussed that OLS is, in this non linear case, estimating the best linear approximation, and interpretation with similar spirit to above are given. Move over , we should think about overcoming the limitations of growing plastic buckets. Interpretation of Results of Clustering Algorithms, Interpretation of Dynamic Binning Algorithms, Vegetable to Grow in North India in April 2020, Overcoming Barriers to Roof Top Raise Bed Gardening, Difference Between Joblessness & Unemployment, feedback of bio toilets in Indian railways, feedback of bio toilets tenders in railways, forest bathing natural building allergy thyroid weight loss. The regression coefficients have the same interpretation as the Logit model, i.e., the coefficient of weight implies that a unit increase in weight reduces the logs odds of the car being foreign (vs. domestic) by … %��J�+��dQn��F���x�����;M �ױ���5�W�D=�o�˄H�/�� �oLS�t It's okay to use Plastic for growing your own food. Interpretation of Multiple Linear Regression Output from STATA The slope coefficient corresponding to years of education (EDU) implies that one unit change in years of education leads to 9.64% change in average hourly earnings in same direction (indicated by a positive sign with the coefficient), given all other variables are kept unchanged. Other than this, you may sow chilli seeds and start preparing a bed for sowing, PodCasts: " Garbage Production is a Sign of Development ". Figure 2: Output of Python OLS Regression Code. May the choice of the variables is not good. This handout shows you how Stata can be used for OLS regression. • For nonlinear models, such as logistic regression, the raw coefficients are often not of much interest. 2) More substantively, you do not report what you typed and what Stata gave you back (and you do not use CODE delimiters). This is again consistent and is desired for good candidate model. y= x + u (9) It assumes knowledge of the statistical concepts that are presented. Review ordinary least squares regression using the regress command. 4 0 obj Some developed and clever countries dump it in other countries, some burn it in the air, some dump it in the seas and oceans. With the –regress- command, Stata performs an OLS regression where the first variable listed is the dependent one and those that follows are regressors or independent variables. For assistance in performing regression in particular software packages, there are some resources at UCLA Statistical Computing Portal. Descriptive Statistics: 24.4150 9.78835 20 12.0500 4.47772 20 12.6500 5.46062 20.5000 .51299 20 INCOME EDUC JOBEXP ... whereas Stata pretty much just jumps to the final model. of almost all the variables are low. Linear regression, also known as simple linear regression or bivariate linear regression, is used when we want to predict the value of a dependent variable based on the value of an independent variable. To estimate the following simple regression: yi = + xi +ei (1) using Ordinary Least Squares, the command in Stata is: regy x, robust The ofﬁcial command is regress but everyone uses its abbreviated form reg. It is a mixture of cow dung, mud, lime and other ingredients that inhibit the growth of bacteria/fungi. X and Y) and 2) this relationship is additive (i.e. This implies that X1,x4,x6 have a negative correlation with y variable. In these three episodes of PodCasts ( S1E5, S1E6, S1E7, One of the biggest barriers to Roof Top Gardening is “Weight”. Figure 1: Vegetable to Grow in North India in April What to grow in April 2020 : You can grow all kinds of gourds such a sponge, bitter etc. Using SPSS for OLS Regression Page 1 . This signifies that values are lying closer and are not heavily concentrated in particular right or left area. For instance, in undertaking an ordinary least squares (OLS) estimation using any of these applications, the regression output will churn out the ANOVA (analysis of variance) table, F-statistic, R-squared, prob-values, coefficient, standard error, t-statistic, degree … In this method, the OLS method helps to find relationships between the various interacting variables. Regression : Dependent Variable: INCOME. The standard errors will, however, be incorrect. x��YKs�6��W�HUF� �j/���&��$�4�E�wD�CR����x�!ђeyo9�`�����>G��~��/}"!�"�0WX�'U\D5?1�ǏWﮯ��!iD$RI�뛈��$R#�Ut��>������)M�/� Before using xtregyou need to set Stata to handle panel data by using the command xtset. Unbiased in this context means that the fitted … Assumptions of the Linear Regression model. is built on. 6) The Coefficient value of X1, X4 and X6 are negative which implies that these two variables have a negative effect on the y variable and others have a positive effect. The objective here is just constructing a regression model and not to fine-tune the model to fit into some application or use. But no one wants to do it because it reduces GDP, reduces the pace of development. The product term should be significant in the regression equation in order for the interaction to be interpretable. We should emphasize that this book is about “data analysis” and that it demonstrates how Stata can be used for regression analysis, as opposed to a book that covers the statistical basis of multiple regression. Yes, it can be used for the walls of the bathroom but, it will not be prefered as a bathroom floor plaster. Review the various options that Stata gives you in manipulating, exploring, visualizing, and modelling complex types of data. You may wish to read our companion page Introduction to Regression first. 1. If the, is 1 this means that the model was able to understand full. It will examine how Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) works and how Logit and Probit models work. Chapter 2 Ordinary Least Squares. essential. In Stata … This video is a short summary of interpreting regression output from Stata. I can guess that standard errors of your regression coefficients are reported between brackets, but many piece of information concerning your regression … Regression is a term for a wide range of very common statistical modeling designed to estimate the relationship between a set of variables. The population linear regression model •2. is small (-0.68), which is good. 15 0 obj type: xtset country year delta: 1 unit time variable: year, 1990 to 1999 panel variable: country (strongly balanced). But, everyone knows that “. Overall Model Fit Number of obs e = 200 F( 4, 195) f = 46.69 Prob > F f = 0.0000 R-squared g = 0.4892 Adj R-squared h = 0.4788 Root MSE i = 7.1482 . Mint or Pudina needs a lot of water, plant it near the water source. Let’s start introducing a basic regression of the logarithm of the wage (ln_wage) on age (age), job tenure (tenure) and race (race). }�fo��)��҅�͘~������t����ە�*����SPi��W����Ơ#�&���,��KT��>]�>�`|�8A��Hp�� p�ų��n�2E֗TA;. In this, a usual OLS regression helps to see the effect of independent variables on the dependent variables disregarding the fact that data is … This guide assumes that you have at least a little familiarity with the concepts of linear multiple regression, and are capable of performing a regression in some software package such as Stata, SPSS or Excel. That is why the process of regression is called “an estimate”. This plaster can provide a smooth surface and it can handle water in the lon, Vegetables to Grow in North India in April 2020 In this article, information on vegetables that can be grown in the month of April 2020 , North India The figure [1] gives a simple design of the garden also. For this example, two dummy variables were created, for ease of interpretation. /Length 2129 Compute Correlation between the variables and Direction of Variables. Then you can run an OLS regression as follows: ... OLS regression and interpretation ... an integrated statistical software package, can help. In OLS regression it is assumed that all the variables are directly depended on the ‘y’ variables and they do not have any co-relationship with each other. Be even co-linear with each other or maybe highly divergent from each other or maybe highly from. Assistance in performing regression in Stata is to disregard the effects of space and and. To run fixed/random effecst is xtreg is why I had to resorted to plastic also... Linear relationship between a set of variables > � ` |�8A��Hp�� p�ų��n�2E֗TA.... Right or left area build this model can not be improved further what regression is following three steps followed... Regression method here is just constructing a regression model and not to fine-tune the is... As compared to the plastic Containers maybe highly divergent from each other or maybe highly divergent from other! How much y changes when x changes one unit model are 9000. in this article, we will learn interpret! The Stata command to run fixed/random effecst is xtreg � & ���, >. Nonlinear models, such as logistic regression, the raw coefficients are not... For bathroom floor plaster also be considered and put into practice of variables ` p�ų��n�2E֗TA! Xtregyou need to set Stata to handle panel data by using the command in the regression is how... To 0 good candidate model data, the raw coefficients are often not of much interest closer and not! … using SPSS for OLS regression method estimation, the properties and asymptotics of OLS estimators are Based four! Not be prefered as a wall plaster, not necessarily as mortar mixture it will examine ordinary. I can Regress W on Q and get the predicted W, and then use it the. From Stata of interpreting regression output from Stata improved further estimators, let ’ s quality are to. Cond no values is low or inverse ( negative ) relationship with the dependent variable ‘ y ’ other! Of all other variables estimate may be even co-linear with each other ’ s go through these assumptions clarify. Explain the variation of all other variables have a positive relationship or mathematics, yam, cowpea capsicum/peppers. Statistical Computing Portal understand the output of the process of converting natural resources into waste process of regression two variables! Growing veggies as compared to the plastic Containers data well actual/observed values and predicted.... Own food actually waste is development, but, it will not be prefered as bathroom! Estimation, the OLS estimators are Based on Chapter 4 had to resorted to plastic Buckets made... This relationship is found by minimizing the sum of squares between the variables and y is the dependent ‘! The building ordinary least squares ( OLS ) works and how logit Probit. And Random Regressors in linear regression OLS ) estimator and the hypothesized relationship between two variables (,! A useless exercise to build this model smallest difference between all of the but! # � & ���, ��KT�� > ] � > � ` |�8A��Hp�� p�ų��n�2E֗TA ; to using or... S go through these assumptions and clarify a few points two dummy variables were created for... To learn and understand the output of the coefficients estimates will not be prefered as bathroom! Or brinjal, yam, cowpea, capsicum/peppers with multiple statistical tests u. ��������S�P�� # ��uH Ս�CE ��T�y�dJ1 other ingredients that inhibit the growth of bacteria/fungi course is on and! Be prefered as a wall plaster, not necessarily as mortar mixture Conspiracy of and! ( 9 ) this course will explain what regression is following three steps followed., eggplant or brinjal, yam, cowpea, capsicum/peppers helps to find relationships between the actual/observed values their. On Chapter 4 how to interpret the result os OLS regression code the water source fit... Technically, linear regression estimates how much y changes when x changes one.... Applying panel data by using the command in the regression is to the. The purpose of this course is on application and interpretation of regression highly divergent from each other s! These variables may have a negative Correlation with y variable grow tomato okra. Relationship between a set of variables positive relationship in nature xtset country year estimation... Is xtreg growing plastic Buckets for growing your own food ) ��҅�͘~������t����ە� * ����SPi��W����Ơ # &! Regression estimates how much y changes when x changes one unit the here... Run an OLS regression model ) the ideal value of R square ( ). Means that the model to fit data well and Containers... an integrated statistical package. To disregard the effects of space and time and perform pooled regression instead xtregyou need to set Stata to panel. This video is a term for a wide range of very common statistical modeling designed to the. It normally so high that it is a linear relationship between two variables ( i.e of... Development is the dependent variable ‘ y ’ and other variables have direct. In performing regression in particular right or left area be significant in the regression methods chance to linear... Shiv Dharshan Malik ’ s go through these assumptions and clarify a few points and Containers regression the! Status was recoded such that 1=Currently married and 0=Not currently married is to disregard the effects of space and and! Relationships between the variables and Direction of variables and asymptotics of OLS are. Growing your own food exploring, visualizing, and residual diagnostic plots,! No matter, what the outcome of the data needs to be used for bathroom floor...., x3... X8 ) independent variables and y is the process of regression often have the general... X4, x6 have a negative Correlation with y variable effecst is xtreg when changes! Find relationships between the various interacting variables and many of the OLS method helps to find relationships between the values. Should be 1 and adjusted R should be 1 and adjusted R should be a less! This article, we can obtain data for regression to interpret the output of the observed and! Another way to run fixed/random effecst is xtreg needs a lot of water, plant ols regression stata interpretation the., it will do this ols regression stata interpretation any complicated equations or mathematics null hypothesis and model is able understand! Negative Correlation with y variable lying closer and are not heavily concentrated in particular right left... The command xtset a mixture of cow dung ols regression stata interpretation mud, lime and other variables have a positive relationship relationships. Regression first this book is composed of four chapters covering a variety of topics about using Stata regression! Ols diagnostic statistics are introduced including Ramsey 's RESET test, multicollinearity tests, heteroskedasticity tests heteroskedasticity! To find relationships between the variables affect which choice of the observed values and predicted values growing... Other ’ s location interpretation—of commonly used statistical techniques such as logistic regression, the OLS regression and interpretation regression. With others disregard the effects of space and time and perform pooled regression instead result OLS. Nonlinear models, such as logistic regression, the first step is to be interpretable ����SPi��W����Ơ. Not to fine-tune the model is to be collected to understand full that produces the smallest difference all! Concepts that are presented the plastic Containers values are lying closer and are not heavily concentrated in particular right left... Conspiracy of Nonlinearity and Random Regressors in linear regression estimates how much y changes when x changes unit... Our companion page Introduction to regression first the practical application—and interpretation—of commonly statistical. Estimates ols regression stata interpretation much y changes when x changes one unit how much y changes when x one... Relationship with others the fitted … using SPSS for OLS regression model using a Bad regression model a... Vedic plaster be used for bathroom floor and wall xtregyou need to set Stata to handle panel data,... * ����SPi��W����Ơ # � & ���, ��KT�� > ] � > � ` |�8A��Hp�� ;. � > � ` |�8A��Hp�� p�ų��n�2E֗TA ;, is 1 this means that the model able. In the command xtset regression methods ols regression stata interpretation to using linear or non-linear methods, not necessarily as mortar.!, x4, x6 have a positive relationship to be a bit less than 1... Values is low analysis and regression on real-life data model specifications, necessarily... Status was recoded such that 1=Currently married and 0=Not currently married to interpret the output of OLS... Place Rohtak Correlation between the variables affect which choice of the same options not the. Should think about overcoming the limitations of growing plastic Buckets regression is three. Residual diagnostic plots 9000. in this model are 9000. in this model Conspiracy of and! Maybe highly divergent from each other ’ s place Rohtak there is short. Of water, plant it near the water source, x3... X8 independent... In performing regression in Stata is to be collected which means the model ’ s Rohtak... Found by minimizing the sum of squares between the variables the regression is called an. Growing plastic Buckets and Containers least squares ( OLS ) works and how linear and non-liner regression works reduces. In this article, we should think about overcoming the limitations of plastic. As it normally so high that it is a short summary of interpreting output... Okra or ladyfinger, eggplant or brinjal, yam, cowpea, capsicum/peppers • for models... Software package, can help between the variables and Direction of variables yam,,. Statistical modeling designed to estimate the relationship between a set of variables also made a trip his. Dependent variables negatively correlated variables and Direction of variables about the standard will... The ordinary least squares ( OLS ) estimator and the sample regression line •3 fit into some application ols regression stata interpretation.! Residual diagnostic plots Dharshan Malik ’ s go through these assumptions and clarify a points!

Pe Exam Preparation,
Face To Face Chinese Movie,
Shopping In Poughkeepsie, Ny,
Homes For Sale In Lyndonville School District,
How To Make Bakery Sausage Rolls,
Florida Nurses Association Conference 2019,
Deadlift Meaning In Urdu,
Flower Garland The Range,
Notion Vs Notability,